By Kristen Belt, RCPC Board
How is it that the proposed project at the Trader Joe's site on College Avenue can be more than 20 stories taller than the 95' zoning limit and still be considered code compliant? (A similar question was posed regarding the senior project proposed on Claremont A venue.)
State Density Bonus (SDB) is a broad policy instrument aimed at increasing the delivery of affordable homes and senior housing, which is in high demand in California. The policy's impact depends heavily on the underlying zoning of any particular site.
There are two different general categories of zoning when it comes to density. Form-based zoning does not restrict density. Rather, it relies on other zoning criteria such as height, bulk, setbacks, and open space to create a legal building zone. Developers may place as many units within this space as they can fit. Developers are required to demonstrate how many units fit within a code-compliant area and are permitted density increases tied to that "base project." In this scenario, a project that qualifies for a 20% density bonus (such as the proposed project at Trader Joe's) would likely only result in an increase of approximately 20% in height.
In contrast, density-restricted sites have a specific allowable density within the zoning code. Developers calculate the allowable number of units based on the zoning code, then layer the density bonus on top. In this scenario, the allowable height within the zoning code is irrelevant. If the zoning allows for 100 units on a site, then the developer can propose 120 units using the SDB 20% bonus for senior housing, regardless of how many stories are needed. The project is entitled to a waiver of any development standard — including building height — that prevents the project from achieving the number of legally allowed units. In this way , the project is "code compliant" using the underlying zoning and SDB with waivers.
Aligning base zoning parameters with neighborhood design intention is challenging. Local planners must address State-mandated housing production goals, while housing legislation is expanding regularly and shifting the planning landscape. Evaluating compliance for large-scale projects such as the proposed T rader Joe's site is complex.
RCPC will closely monitor the planning approvals process for the site, advocate for community benefits with both the developer and the City , and count on our neighborhood land use attorneys to verify alignment with zoning and housing laws.

